At the recent NITI Aayog Governing Council meeting in New Delhi, the contrast between Punjab and Haryana couldn’t have been starker. Haryana came with a blueprint for the future; Punjab arrived with a laundry list of complaints. The divergence wasn’t just symbolic—it laid bare two vastly different models of governance, ambition, and political culture.
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Pledge your support
Haryana Chief Minister Nayab Singh Saini pitched a bold, data-backed vision of transforming his state into a $1 trillion economy by 2047, powered by AI, skill development, innovation, and industrial corridors. Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann, in contrast, focused on seeking funds for border infrastructure and water from the Yamuna to sustain paddy cultivation. Necessary concerns, no doubt—but indicative of a state stuck in survival mode rather than aiming for resurgence.
Punjab’s Grievance Politics Is Not Governance
For decades, Punjab’s political class has relied on the rhetoric of grievance—over water-sharing, border status, and historic injustices. While these issues matter, they have become a substitute for economic planning. The state has mastered the art of lament, but not the discipline of leadership. At a moment meant for national planning, Punjab again played the victim—asking, not envisioning.
Grievance is not governance. And Punjab’s reflexive reliance on it has become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Haryana’s Leap Ahead: Vision Backed by Execution
Haryana, in contrast, has capitalized on its proximity to Delhi, leveraged its cities like Gurugram as startup magnets, and promoted itself as a hub for industrial investment and innovation. Its policies—such as a ₹2,000 crore innovation fund and emphasis on quantum computing, AI, and EV infrastructure—are not mere announcements, but part of a systemic effort to prepare for the future.
Haryana has not just embraced industrialization—it has built a culture of welcoming enterprise. That has made all the difference.
Ludhiana Economic Corridor: Punjab CM’s Bold Plan at Risk
Ironically, Punjab has one truly ambitious idea on the table: a plan to acquire 24,000 acres near Ludhiana under a land pooling scheme aligned with the Jammu-Katra-Delhi expressway. If executed, it could transform Ludhiana into North India’s manufacturing and logistics hub, offering farmers long-term value while creating jobs and attracting capital.
But the plan is now under siege—most vehemently by the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD), the very party that pioneered land pooling in New Chandigarh under GMADA. The hypocrisy is stunning. Leaders who allegedly profited from underhand land deals in GMADA now oppose a similar scheme, labelling it anti-farmer. This isn’t opposition rooted in principle; it’s political sabotage dressed in populist language.
If Punjab squanders this chance due to infighting and short-term politics, it will be yet another missed opportunity in a growing list.
Anti-Corporate Mindset: Punjab’s Self-Inflicted Wound
Punjab’s image in corporate boardrooms is damaged—and deservedly so. A deep-seated suspicion of corporates, fostered by political rhetoric and a history of protests, has made investors wary. Industrial proposals are stalled, projects protested, and bureaucratic red tape flourishes. Meanwhile, Haryana and even Himachal Pradesh quietly scoop up the investments fleeing Punjab.
This anti-corporate culture is not just misguided—it’s suicidal. Industry does not grow where it is feared or vilified. Punjab has become a high-risk, low-trust environment, and the youth pay the price in unemployment and forced migration.
Missed Opportunities: Agro-Processing and Green Energy
Punjab is blessed with fertile soil and entrepreneurial farmers, but it remains stuck in an outdated, water-guzzling model of agriculture. Paddy cultivation, once a Green Revolution triumph, is now an environmental and economic liability.
Yet Punjab is sitting on two untapped goldmines:
Post-harvest agro-processing, which could multiply farm incomes and reduce wastage
Agro-waste-to-energy, which could combat stubble burning, generate clean energy, and create rural jobs
These sectors have transformative potential. But without serious investment and a long-term strategy, they remain PowerPoint slides instead of policy.
Stop Blaming, Start Building
Punjab must break free from the narrative of victimhood. Yes, there are structural challenges—border insecurity, central apathy, water disputes. But the harsh truth is: Punjab is now held back less by Delhi, and more by its own political inertia and cultural stagnation.
We must stop pretending that external factors alone are to blame. The future is being written by states that plan boldly and act decisively—Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, and now Haryana. Punjab must join that league, or be left behind.
A Call to Action: Strategy, Not Slogans
Punjab doesn’t need pity—it needs purpose. It doesn’t need freebie politics—it needs fiscal reform. It doesn’t need saviours—it needs leaders with spine and vision.
The Ludhiana corridor must be defended, not derailed. The corporate climate must be rebuilt, not resisted. The agricultural economy must evolve, not wither. And the political discourse must grow up, because the world will not wait for Punjab to catch up.