Chandigarh, November 20: In a significant development concerning the Punjab Civil Services (PCS) recruitment process, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has directed the Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC) to immediately preserve and seal the entire recruitment record, citing serious procedural irregularities and concerns over the fairness and transparency of the selection process.The court’s direction comes amid multiple petitions challenging the recruitment process initiated through an advertisement dated January 2, 2025, for which more than 85,000 candidates reportedly applied.
Justice Sandeep Moudgil, while hearing the matter, observed that the concerns raised by the petitioners appeared prima facie serious and could potentially affect the careers of hundreds of candidates if the selection process were allowed to continue without proper examination.
In its detailed 21-page order, the High Court highlighted several alleged shortcomings in the recruitment process.One of the major concerns involved repeated extensions of deadlines for submitting documents, particularly for candidates applying under the Sports and Persons with Disabilities (PwD) categories. The court noted that deadlines had reportedly been extended on nearly three occasions, allegedly without a formal decision by the Commission or the state government.The court also questioned why the scrutiny of applications had not been completed before the preliminary and main examinations. According to the order, scrutiny was completed only on November 18, even though the PCS mains result had already been declared on November 4.
The High Court also took note of discrepancies in question papers. Some papers reportedly contained serial numbers, while others did not. Differences in the patterns and fonts of serial numbers further raised questions about the genuineness and uniformity of the examination material.Another issue concerned candidates who allegedly submitted applications under different genders and received roll numbers in both male and female categories. The court also flagged cases involving multiple roll numbers being issued to several applicants.
The court expressed concern over the subsequent opportunities provided to candidates to submit Sports Gradation Certificates.It observed that repeated extensions could have disadvantaged candidates who had complied with the original deadline. According to the court’s observations, these extensions prima facie increased the number of eligible candidates by 361, who otherwise might not have been eligible even to appear in the preliminary examination.The court also questioned the pattern of successful candidates in the declared result, stating that certain circumstances and instances highlighted by the petitioners raised suspicion.
The High Court has directed the PPSC Secretary to preserve and seal the complete record relating to the recruitment process, covering everything from the submission of applications to the scrutiny completed up to November 18.The sealed record must be submitted to the court by November 23.The court has already stayed further proceedings in the selection process under the concerned advertisement.
Emphasising the constitutional principles of equality and fairness, the court observed that recruitment to public posts must comply with Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, ensuring transparency, non-arbitrariness and equal opportunity for all eligible candidates.The court further clarified that allegations of irregularities in public recruitment need not necessarily be established through direct evidence of cheating at this preliminary stage.The matter has been listed for further hearing on December 16.